| Institute for Planetary Health Behaviour

When science is uncertain: developing research communication that is accessible to the public, in collaboration with citizens

How can scientific uncertainty be communicated in a way that is both understandable and inspires trust? The UncertainTEAM project is exploring this question in participatory workshops with citizens of Thuringia. Together, participants develop ideas on how research findings and uncertainties can be better contextualised in everyday life. Their perspectives are incorporated directly into further research and research communication.

How can scientific uncertainty be communicated in a way that remains understandable, provides guidance and, at the same time, does not unnecessarily undermine trust in science and research? Participatory workshops involving members of the public from Thuringia are currently addressing this question. Together with the participants, the project is exploring how people experience science in their everyday lives, what helps them make sense of research findings, and how scientific uncertainty can be presented in a way that is understandable from their perspective. In doing so, the organisers are deliberately visiting locations outside the major cities to involve people with diverse experiences and points of contact with science.

The workshops combine research communication and participatory research. Right from the start, participants contribute their own experiences of science and research: where they encounter scientific findings in their daily lives, the ways in which they seek information, what helps them to understand and make sense of the information, and what expectations they have regarding the communication of research findings. In the workshop, science is made accessible and tangible. Using storytelling, illustrative charts, concrete examples of studies and materials from the field of research communication, the workshop leader explains how scientific findings emerge, how studies are conducted and results interpreted, and how research is ultimately communicated. Using examples from the health sector in particular, it becomes clear that scientific findings are not always unambiguous or definitive: results may differ from one another, measurements and methods have their limitations, and new research can alter existing knowledge. Scientific uncertainty is thus not explained in abstract terms, but made comprehensible through concrete cases. For people who have had little or no direct contact with research to date, the workshop therefore offers the opportunity to better contextualise scientific processes and understand why uncertainty is a normal part of research. 

The participatory development section of the workshop builds on this: using a current example, participants work together to explore how scientific uncertainties can be presented in an understandable way. They develop their own ideas about what information is necessary, which phrasing is clear, and which forms of presentation can provide guidance. Citizens are thus not merely consulted on existing communication materials, but develop their own ideas and solutions. Their everyday experiences, expectations and difficulties in understanding become an active part of the research process. 

This is precisely where the strength of the participatory approach lies: research communication is not just developed for members of the public, but with them. The workshops create a space where knowledge flows in both directions: researchers explain how science works and why uncertainty is an inherent part of research; citizens contribute what they need to understand, what questions arise for them, and which forms of communication are actually helpful in everyday life. 

It is impressive to see how openly and enthusiastically the participants discuss science. Many want to understand exactly how research works, whilst at the same time sharing very personal experiences of what helps them to understand or where uncertainties arise. These insights are extremely valuable to us because they show how research communication can be designed even more effectively from the public’s perspective.

Dr Sabine Best, head of the subproject

The perspectives gained are being incorporated into further research within the UncertainTEAM project and will help to communicate scientific uncertainty in a way that is more tailored to the target audience in future. This is because the workshops form part of a research project funded by the BMFTR, entitled ‘UncertainTEAM – Target-group-appropriate communication of scientific uncertainty in multiple crises’, based at the Institute for Planetary Health Behaviour at the University of Erfurt. An interdisciplinary team comprising experts in communication studies, sociology, educational research, psychology and health communication is using a mixed-methods approach to investigate how scientific uncertainty can be communicated in a way that is tailored to specific target groups. In addition to the workshops with members of the public, interviews with journalists and experimental studies are also being conducted.

Contact:

Research Associate
(Department of Media and Communication Studies)
C19 – research building "Weltbeziehungen" / C19.01.22