For the study, Professor Guido Mehlkop (University of Erfurt), Dr Sebastian Sattler (University of Bielefeld) and Fiona Seiffert (University of Cologne) analysed the responses of 1,331 people. They were surveyed between October and December 2022 as part of a nationwide random sample. In an experiment, respondents were randomly assigned one of two options: free one-to-one tuition regardless of academic performance, or tuition only for children with poor academic performance.
Those who were offered the second option were more supportive of the support scheme, considered it fairer and viewed the parents more positively than the control group. The researchers suggest that many people likely interpret such eligibility criteria as an indication that the support is genuinely necessary and that the children are entitled to it.
Worldview is linked to approval
People with left-wing political views consistently express greater support for the measure. Support is lower amongst those who consider social hierarchies to be justified – referred to in research as social dominance orientation – and amongst those with more pronounced envious resentment.
“Unfavourable social starting conditions alone are apparently not enough for everyone to justify support,” says Guido Mehlkop, a sociologist at the University of Erfurt. “This raises a fundamental question for our welfare state: do we want to compensate for disadvantages at an early stage, or only help once problems have already become apparent?”
“It is astonishing how little one’s own material circumstances explain the issue: the respondents’ income and education play hardly any role,” says Sebastian Sattler, a sociologist at the University of Bielefeld. “Whether people support such support depends less on whether they themselves might benefit, and more on their vision of a just society and also on envy towards those who receive help. The debate over educational equity thus tends to revolve around values rather than interests.”
According to the study, whether the public supports redistribution in education depends not only on the aim, but also on who is to receive the support. This applies even to measures that, in principle, enjoy broad approval. The authors comment: “Those who link support to poor academic performance do indeed gain approval. However, the differences between the political camps remain.”
Original publication:
Guido Mehlkop, Sebastian Sattler, Fiona Seiffert: Who Supports Redistributive Education Policies? Attitudes Toward Free Tutoring for Socioeconomically Disadvantaged Children Conditional or Unconditional on Academic Performance. Cologne Journal of Sociology and Social Psychology, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11577-026-01099-0, published on 9 November 2026